|
What this covers
|
Every tunneling materials supplier has a reference list. Some are a page of project names. Some are detailed case studies with machine types, ground conditions and site photos.
If you write specifications or approve submittals, the difference matters. A reference list can tell you a great deal about whether a material will work on your drive, or almost nothing at all. Here is how to read one.
What a Reference Is Supposed to Prove
A reference is evidence that a material has been used, under real conditions, with a known result. That is all it can prove, and it is a lot.
For it to be useful to you, a reference has to answer three questions:
- Was the job similar to mine in machine type and size?
- Was the ground similar to mine?
- What was measured, and what changed?
A project name with no details answers none of those. A case study with the machine, the ground and the measured result answers all three.
Machine Type Comes First
Tunnel boring machines and pipe jackers work in different ways, and a material that suits one may play a different role in another.
|
Machine type |
What it does |
What an annular material is asked to do |
|
Pipe jacker |
Pushes a string of pipes from a shaft |
Lubricate the pipe string over the drive length, support the overcut |
|
Earth pressure balance (EPB) TBM |
Holds the face with excavated soil under pressure |
Support the annular gap around the shield and help hold chamber pressure |
|
Slurry shield TBM |
Holds the face with pressurized slurry |
Fill and seal the annular gap, including at launch |
|
Vertical shaft sinking machine |
Sinks a shaft rather than boring horizontally |
Different use case, read the details closely |
When you read a reference list, sort it by machine type first. A strong record on slurry shields says less about a pipe jacking drive than the project names might suggest.
Size and Shape Tell You About Scale
Diameter or section size tells you about the scale of the annular gap, the forces involved and the volume of material used.
A good reference list states the size of each machine. One real list, for example, runs from a 4.91 m slurry shield up to a 15.1 m vertical shaft sinking machine, with EPB TBMs at 6.69 m, 8.8 m, 9.13 m, 11.66 m, 11.76 m and 11.85 m, slurry shields at 9 m, 11.64 m and 14.57 m, and rectangular EPB pipe jackers of 8.7 m by 9.9 m and 7.63 m by 6.43 m.
A spread like that tells you the material has been used across a wide range of sizes and machine types. It does not tell you how it did on any one of them. For that, you need the case studies.
Ground Conditions Are the Real Test
Two drives with the same machine can behave completely differently in different ground. So the most important line in any case study is the ground description.
Look for specifics. “Soft ground” says little. “Silty sand in a strongly permeable artesian aquifer” says a lot. Look for the depth, the water conditions and any special risks, such as liquefaction, mixed ground or a crossing beneath a river.
Then compare with your own geotechnical report. A reference in ground like yours is worth more than ten in ground that is easier.
Depth and water deserve a separate look. A material that performed in shallow, dry ground may behave very differently under high water pressure at depth, even in the same soil type. If your alignment runs below the water table, filter the reference list for projects that also did. If it crosses beneath a river or runs through an artesian aquifer, look for those words specifically in the case studies. A short list of truly comparable projects is more useful than a long list of loosely similar ones, and it gives you specific questions to ask the supplier about each one.
What Was Measured, and What Changed
The strongest references describe a problem, a change and a measured result.
That might be jacking force before and after a change of lubricant. It might be pressure at a launch portal, leakage at a penetration, or chamber pressure at the face. The useful part is that something was measured and the result is stated.
Weak references describe the material in general terms and say the project was a success. They may be true. They just cannot be checked.
Strong and Weak References Side by Side
The difference between a reference that helps you and one that does not is usually obvious once you put them next to each other.
|
Element |
Weak reference |
Strong reference |
|
Machine |
“TBM project” |
Machine type, maker and diameter |
|
Ground |
“Difficult conditions” |
Soil type, water conditions, depth and special risks |
|
Problem |
Not stated |
The specific issue the material was used to address |
|
Result |
“Successful” |
A measured value, or a clear before and after |
|
Evidence |
None |
Site photos, monitoring data, or a published paper |
|
Contact |
None offered |
A contractor or engineer you can speak to |
Most real reference lists sit somewhere in the middle. Some entries are detailed and some are just names. That is normal. What matters is whether the detailed entries include projects like yours.
It also helps to note what a reference does not say. A case study that reports stable chamber pressure but says nothing about settlement may simply not have measured it. Ask before you assume. The answer is often available, but it was not the point of that write-up.
Finally, look at the dates. A reference from the last few years, with a stated project year, tells you the material and the supplier are active now. An old list with no dates may still be valid, but it is worth asking what has changed since.
An Example of a Useful Case Study
The Shenzhen Shenda Railroad T4 Tunnel Project is a good example of what a useful case study contains.
The machine is stated: a 9.13 m CRCHI duo mode slurry and EPB TBM, with a project year of 2024. The scope is stated: a section with 6 stations and 5 interstations, a total construction length of 31.816 km, on a railway of approximately 69.2 km with 11 stations, designed for 160 km/h. The ground is stated: complex geology including soft soils, sand layers and rock strata.
The risks are listed too. The TBM was to pass beneath integrated utility tunnels, airport runways, an airport terminal building, airport drainage culverts, a subway station, ramp bridges and a golf course.
Then the problem and the result. Pressure control had failed and soil was spewing from the screw conveyor. A thixotropic grout was injected through reserved grouting holes in the mid-shield to form a pressurized annular ring. Soil chamber pressure was maintained and the screw conveyor stopped spewing soil. Site camera images before and after are included.
That is a reference you can test against your own drive. You can read the full account in the Shenda T4 chamber pressure case.
Questions to Ask About Any Reference List
- How many of these projects used the same machine type as ours?
- Which ones were in ground like ours, and what was the depth?
- Which ones include measured results, and can we see them?
- Were there any projects where the material did not perform, and why?
- Can we speak to the contractor or engineer on a comparable project?
The last question is the strongest test. A supplier confident in its record will usually help you reach someone who used the material.
Keep the answers with the submittal. If the material is approved, those notes explain why. If something goes wrong later, they show what was checked and what was assumed, which protects everyone involved in the decision.
Using References in a Specification
References belong in the submittal, but the spec can say what kind of reference counts. A short clause that asks for at least one project with the same machine type, in comparable ground, with measured results, sets a clear bar without naming a product.
You can also ask for published work. Papers and conference proceedings go through a review process and often contain more detail than a marketing page. Where a supplier has published on a material, that is worth reading alongside the case studies. Read the method sections in particular. They show how a result was measured, which is the part a summary page usually leaves out.
One supplier that publishes detailed tunneling project references for annular grout is Balsam Laboratory, whose list covers 18 documented projects in China, Singapore and Canada across EPB, slurry shield and pipe jacking machines, with individual case studies setting out the machine, the ground and the measured result.
The Short Version
A reference list proves only what it states. Sort it by machine type, check the size, and read the ground conditions against your own geotechnical report.
Give the most weight to case studies that describe a problem, a change and a measured result. Ask to see the data, ask about projects in ground like yours, and write the kind of reference you need into the spec so every supplier is measured against the same bar.





























